Ok...before I tell you, Jordan got asked a few days later by Mykell Hass to the Sweethearts dance also.

So...two girls, two treats...ONE ANSWER!! How convenient huh....Well, the answer is...

They are getting a gallon or whatever size it is, of Sherbet ice cream...and the saying...You "Sher - bet" I'll go to the dance with you". Kind of silly and lame, but it's done and that's all that matters. (Does everyone get it?)
P.S. Alaina, I loved your ideas and will keep those for the next time...we had all ready come up with this when I read your comments.
P.S.S. Beth, are you crazy...me making a tickle me Elmo cake...cute idea but not happening in this household....they are lucky to get dinner. LOL.